Persuasion Book Review

Disclosure statement

Robert Morrichild has got capital from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Parts of this essay were initially publiburned in the Review to his Harvard College Press edition of Jane Austen’s Persuasion.

Partners

*

Queen's University, Ontario gives funding as a beginning partner of The Conversation CA.

You watching: Persuasion book review

Queen's University, Ontario gives capital as a member of The Conversation CA-FR.

View all partners


When I was asked a few years back if I would favor to edit among Jane Austen’s novels, I quickly answered that I would certainly be happy to, and particularly if I can modify her greatest novel.

“I’m sorry, Rob,” was the reply. “Someone is already modifying Pride and also Prejudice.”

“That’s ok,” I shelp, a lot relieved. “Pride and also Prejudice is not Austen’s biggest novel. Jane Austen’s biggest novel is Persuasion.”

It is – among many type of other points – the most moving love story she ever told. Anne Elliot is the second daughter of the absurdly vain baronet Sir Wtransform Elliot of Kellynch Hall. Frederick Wentworth is an officer in the British navy throughout the Napoleonic Wars.


Eight years prior to the novel starts, Wentworth proposes to Anne and she accepts him after a brief and also intense courtship, only to be encouraged by her father and her older frifinish Lady Russell to break off the engagement. Wentworth, angry and badly hurt, goes back to sea, wbelow he conducts a successful series of raiding explorations on foe ships, and amasses a fortune in prize money.

When Napoleon abdicates for the first time in April 1814, Wentworth returns to England also and also soon pays a visit to his sister, that currently stays close to Anne. Throughout his absence, meanwhile, Anne has actually found no one that compares to him, and also has actually pined ameans to the point where currently, at 27 years old, her bloom is gone and she has actually started the descent right into spinsterhood.

Many type of doubters have actually said that, as a result of suffering and regret, Anne is currently “mature” as soon as the novel opens, while the affluent and caretotally free Wentworth has actually an excellent deal of growing as much as execute prior to he recognizes – or, rather, re-recognizes – her worth.

On the contrary, for all that divides them as soon as he returns, Anne has as much to learn around love as Wentworth does, and her journey towards their reconciliation consists of as much confusion as his. Indeed, part of the substantial appeal of Persuasion is Austen’s capability to convey the ways in which Wentworth and Anne are moving steadily toward one an additional even as their assorted misprocedures, flirtations and presumptions seem to be driving them still further apart.

See more: Book Review: Way Of The Reaper Book Review : Way Of The Reaper By Nick Irving

Their reunion is the finest scene in all of Austen, and also in it they carry out not even sheight face to challenge, for Austen interpreted that mediated and also misdirected messperiods commonly carry a far higher charge than explicit declarations.

Anne and also Wentworth are both in a room at the White Hart Inn in Bath. He is sitting at a desk writing a letter. She is adjacent speaking to a common frifinish, Captain Harville, around men, women and also constancy.

Harville believes that males feel even more deeply than women. Anne takes the opposite view, and also while she does not cite Wentworth or her very own circumstances, everything she claims is plainly via him in mind.

She has actually spoken to no one about her grief over Wentworth, and it is not lengthy before eight years of pent-up anguish flood out of her. “We definitely perform not forobtain you, so shortly as you forobtain us,” she tells Harville. “It is, possibly, our fate quite than our merit. We cannot assist ourselves. We live at house, quiet, confined, and our feelings prey upon us.”

Wentworth, still composing his letter, overhears Anne’s comments and also knows automatically that she is speaking about their relationship, and about all that has actually been shed.

Seizing another sheet of paper, he begins a 2nd letter in which he records his feelings towards her as she utters hers towards him, and also which he leaves behind on the desk for her to check out.

*
Captain Wentworth shows his letter to Anne, via eyes of glowing entreaty solved on her. (C. E. Brock)

Ralph Waldo Emerkid objected to Austen’s novels bereason he discovered them “imprisoned in the wretched conventions of English culture, without genius, wit, or knowledge of the civilization.”

But Austen kbrand-new that love is the extremely biggest issue of life, then as currently, and in Persuasion she makes Anne’s entirety people hang on a solitary letter. It is a minute that demonstrates both the superb compression and also the enthroughout appeal of her art.

If Wentworth loves Anne, she has a future that stretches as far as the seas. If he does not, she has actually only a past that will certainly increasingly consume her. She reads the letter. He does love her. Her joy is inexpressible. So is ours.

What’s more, Austen has actually contrived to tell both Anne and also the reader at the exact same time, and her passionate affirmation of personal preference and individual desire far transcends the “wretched conventions of English culture.”

“You pierce my soul,” Wentworth’s letter reads. “I am half agony, fifty percent hope. Tell me not that I am also late, that such priceless feelings are gone for ever before. I market myself to you aobtain via a heart also even more your very own, than once you practically damaged it eight years and a half earlier.” Anne is overwhelmed.

During the novel she has been transformed, from faded to blooming, from nobody to somebody, from “just Anne” within her family members to Wentworth’s “just Anne.”

Persuasion is Austen’s last publiburned occupational. She began it when she was practically 40 years old, and as soon as she finished it she was within a year of her fatality. Perhaps not surprisingly, it is among her shortest – and it is definitely her saddest – novel.

But it is also her subtlest and also a lot of impassioned. “After a long immersion in work,” British novelist Martin Amis writes, “I find that her thought rhythms entirely attack my own.”

For me, nowright here are Austen’s “believed rhythms” even more haunting than in Anne’s conversation through Harville, and also Wentworth’s response to her in his letter. More generally, in its blend of the public and the personal, Persuasion explores both the torment of silence and the value of hope.