While atmospheric and loaded with potential, Nightfall falls short of the note in terms of scares or general plot cohesion. In simple words, Nightfall is readable, however inevitably a forgettable disappointment of a novel.

You watching: Nightfall book review

Title: Nightfall

Author: Jake Halpern & Peter Kujawinski

Genre: Horror, Speculative Fiction, Young Adult

Publisher: G.P. Putnam Sun’s for Young ReadersPublication Date: July 2015Paperback: 368 pages

The dark will certainly lug your worst nightmares to light, in this gripping and also eerie survival story, perfect for fans of James Dashner and Neil Gaiman.

On Marin’s island, sunrise doesn’t come eincredibly twenty-4 hours—it comes every twenty-eight years. Now the sun is just a sliver of light on the horizon. The weather is turning cold and also the shadows are prospering long.

Because suncollection triggers the tide to roll out hundreds of miles, the islanders are frantically preparing to sail southern, wright here they will certainly wait out the long Night.

See more: The Book By The Sidemen Book Review : The Sideman, By Caro Ramsay

Marin and also her twin brvarious other, Kana, help their anxious parental fees all set the house for leave. Locks need to be taken off doors. Furniture have to be arranged. Tables should be set. The rituals are puzzling—bizarre, even—but namong the adults in town will certainly discuss why it hregarding be done this way.

Just as the ships are about to sail, a teenage boy goes missing—the twins’ frifinish Line. Marin and Kana are the only ones who know the fact about wright here Line’s gone, and the just method to rescue him is by doing it themselves. But Night is falling. Their island also is altering.

And it may already be too late.

Stand alone or series: Standalone novel

How did I acquire this book: ARC from the publisher

Style (e- or p-): Print

Why did I read this book: I obtained a super fancy ARC from the publisher with intriguing instructions “to the grasp of the house”–and then I read the synopsis and also was instantly hooked.


Of course, the trouble through a tantalizing premise like this, and such a vast encompassing question, is that the novel is just as excellent as its answers (or its promise to answer things). Nightfall, disappointingly, has few answers. Alongside Marin, Line, and also Kana, we readers learn that the majority of things happen in Bliss bereason that’s the way it has always been done–the villagers prepare for the lengthy journey to the Desert Lands, they pay the furriers in goods and food to ferry them to their second house, they follow starray instructions to clean and prepared their dwellings on Bliss to coincide through the coming of night. Marin concerns that logic proactively in the text, but is met through the very same bland also answers that things are the method they are bereason that’s the method they are. It’s not satisfying for Marin (and definitely not satisfying for me as a reader, either).

Beyond the absence of answers, yet, the most frustrating thing about Nightfall is the truth that nopoint really happens. Well, that’s inspecific. A lot of stuff happens, however all of it is useless activity and produced stress and anxiety. There’s no larger thought or plot–the premise is all tbelow is, and also then 3 youngsters running around from peril to peril, climbing trees and cliff walls as they try to evade the monsters in the dark and also uncover a means to leave the island. There are no astronomical revelations around the people or why points happen, just that…they perform. It’s a small disappointing, to say the leastern.

And as soon as the plotting doesn’t work-related, every little thing else gets scrutinized. For example, let’s look at the worldbuilding and also rule-specifying in this book. How perform the 14 years of uninterrupted day work? This is fantasy and also suspension of disidea is excellent and all, but I was hoping for something even more than simply arbitrary periods for sunincrease versus sunset. How deserve to this job-related via daylight continuous for years in one place, and also then 6 day night cycles in the desert (a location cshed enough to travel by ship and also sea on smallish fishing vessels)? The analogy for us would be Alaska or north Scandinavian countries (or locations within the Antarctic circle, to the southerly hemisphere), enduring their polar midnight sunlight and polar night–however this is because of Earth’s axial tilt, and only lasting for days instead of years, and better transforming as the Earth proceeds its journey roughly the sun. How does it work for Bliss and the Desert Lands? What are the eco-friendly and also societal effects of expanded daylight? Wouldn’t these be a lot deeper and also even more pervasive than monsters and ice–we’re talking around food and crops, diet, pet life, vegetation, behavorial worries. Granted, this is not the allude or thrust of the book at all… but I can’t aid yet wonder bereason the establishing is pure home window dressing for produced stress, and also that drives me to distractivity. (As a side note, this book can be a helpful instance to teach the equinoxes and solstices, to teach around a planet’s tilt and rotation, and to suggest out nonfeeling in arbitrary specfic.)

Tbelow are various other things too–the monsters in the dark, for instance. Wright here are they lying dormant? Is it that they hibernate for fourteen years in their mysterious door vaults in a different dimension (or something)? What carry out they eat as soon as they come out of that hibernation!? Are they just on the island? Who are the furriers, and also how did they even find the Bliss dwellers, and those create the Desert Lands? Why?

All this is exacerbated even more by the writing style of the book–simplistic in tone and framework, through awkward chapter breaks and protagonists that tfinish to react and speak in methods that don’t rather make feeling. Characterization suffers as an outcome of this as well, as we obtain glimmers of promising inner arcs for Marin and brother Kana, for Line and his connection via both siblings… but glimmers without any actual delivery they reprimary until the book’s finish.

All in all, Nightfall isn’t a bad book–but it’s not one I’d recommfinish either.