Love rosie book review

Home / Book vs Movie / Books / Books Resee / Movie Resee / Movies / Publication Versus Movie: Where Rainbows End vs Love, Rosie
*

2004 saw the release of Wbelow Rainbows End by Cecilia Ahern, a book told via emails and letters neighboring the friendship between two characters, Rosie Dunne and also Alex Stewart, following from their childhood well right into their adult lives. The book was very successful and also so, a decade later, an adaptation Love, Rosie was released, starring Lily Collins and Sam Claflin.

You watching: Love rosie book review


The fundamental premise of both stories is that of 2 ideal friends who covertly have a thing for each other, and just never before acquire together because life keeps acquiring in the means. The book and the movie discover exactly how straightforward it is for two human being to miss out on each various other if they don"t make the ideal options, if they aren"t brave enough to seek what they want. Both our characters make stupid decisions and also poor options, specifically in the book, yet they are always part of each other"s lives, simply never before in the right area.
*
Rosie and also Alex met once they were young youngsters, and also immediately came to be best friends. Initially things are exceptionally innocent, yet they are inseparable. As time goes on and they prosper up, they start to face even more teenage troubles, such as crushes on human being from their school and the reality civilization execute typically mistake them for a pair. It"s rather tender to check out their friendship from the extremely moment it begins, and to follow it blooming over the years.
*
In the book, Alex ends up moving to Boston with his household in their teenagers, leaving Rosie behind in Dublin. In the movie, Alex doesn"t move to America till he is embraced into Harvard. In both, Alex and also Rosie setup for Rosie to come over to Boston and also begin their adult stays together. Tbelow appears to be rather of an unspoken knowledge between them that as soon as they"re back in the same nation they would certainly favor to view where points go. Unfortunately, Rosie never before gets there because at her school formal, she ends up gaining pregnant and also the life they planned together instantly disappears as their futures diverge.

See more: Review Of “ The Pieces We Keep Book Review, The Pieces We Keep


*

Rosie starts building a life for her and also her daughter, Katie, as Alex starts pursing a clinical career in America and also meets a woman named Sally, who he marries. While in the book, Alex and also Sally seem prefer a sensibly happy couple with a actual chance, in the movie Sally is shown as some vapid, pretentious bitch. I didn"t want Sally to be the negative man of the story, as that shouldn"t have been the emphasis. It should have actually been that she wasn"t ideal for Alex, as nice as she seemed, ssuggest bereason he was in love with someone else.
*

The book sees Rosie fulfill and marry a male named Greg, while in the movie Greg is actually Katie"s father and also the boy Rosie had a crush on for years at institution. In both Greg turns out to be the wrong guy for Rosie, not dealing with her the way she deserves to be treated and cheating on her. Greg have the right to view Rosie and Alex are very close, and is extremely jealous of their attachment to each various other as well as their history, and also goes so far as to spitecompletely steal a very tender letter Alex sends out to Rosie expressing his feelings to her. Because she never sees it, she does not respond to his pledge to make her happy if she would certainly just offer him a possibility, and so he leaves his feelings aside as he believes she has favored Greg. It"s incredibly sad to watch someone Rosie trusted and also treatment for want to intentionally speak her from being happy, however it"s somepoint the majority of civilization can relate to.
I read Wright here Rainbows End years earlier, and also I loved it. I never before thought it would be made into a film. A component of me never before wanted it to be a film, reason I kbrand-new the sweeping love story between Rosie and also Alex portrayed in the book wouldn"t interpret well into a movie. The run time of a movie simply wouldn"t enable it; in the film they just around regulated to present 12 years of a friendship, whereas in the book we cover 45 years. The writers of the movie were never before going to be able to portray things as they were in the book, and also I made my peace with it when I decided to go check out the film last year, largely. What I couldn"t make my tranquility through was the love story in between Rosie and also Alex being reduced to the principle that guys and girls can not be "just friends". Especially with the tag line for among the posters I experienced which review "it"s never too late to fall in love via a mate." That line irked me, regarding me it plainly indicated the movie missed the allude. The book is about soulmates, about destiny bringing 2 world together no issue what.
*

I will provide the screenauthors points for trying. Where Rainbows End was constantly going to be tough to analyze right into another tool, because the book is simply letters and emails and also messperiods. So I appreciated the effort. Plus the spreading of Collins and Claflin was fantastic, and also the chemistry in between them was compelling, so again well done.
I did genuinely gain the film, despite just how I"ve made it sound up till this allude. It was funny and also romantic. There were moments I was laughing, moments I kbrand-new exactly exactly how the characters felt, moments when I was virtually refsupplied to tears. In itself, it was a beautiful film, just not choose the book.Wbelow Rainbows Endmade me realise I didn"t must understand exactly what my next action remained in life, because possibilities were it wasn"t going to occupational out like that anymeans. It made me reassess what I believed about thriving up and also finding your soulmate, that making mistakes along the method was okay as long as I never provided up on complying with my heart.Love, Rosiedidn"t give me the exact same feeling, sadly. It was a shame Rosie and also Alex didn"t age even more, as it would have given the story a little more substance to remember simply how lengthy had actually gone by as they circled each other, both as well afrassist. By missing those messages I think this movie will certainly be remembered as simply an additional chick flick, which is a real shame.
This is a short summary in the author block around the author. You modify it by entering message in the "Biographical Info" area in the user admin panel.